Skip to content

AvaTrade vs. IG

AvaTrade vs. IG: fees, tradable products, platforms, deposits and withdrawals, regulation and service – feature by feature.

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. The majority of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs.

Key facts at a glance

IG leads our rating with 4.3 out of 5. Fees at AvaTrade: Spreads ab 0,9 Pips (EUR/USD), keine separate Kommission. Fees at IG: Spreads ab 1 Punkt DAX, ab 0,6 Punkte EUR/USD; Knock-outs 0 € Kommission. AvaTrade is supervised by Central Bank of Ireland, CySEC, ASIC, FSCA, FSA Japan, FSRA (ADGM), FSC BVI, CMA Kenia. IG is supervised by BaFin, Deutsche Bundesbank.

AvaTrade: Editorial rating
3.6/5
IG: Editorial rating
4.3/5

Updated: · Reviewed by BrokerCheck24 editorial team · Missing values (–) are not verified by us; we never estimate them.

AvaTrade Logo
AvaTrade

Irish-regulated CFD broker with MetaTrader and copy trading

Visit provider * Read review
Higher rating
IG Logo
IG

CFD and forex broker with a German entity in Frankfurt and a wide choice of platforms

Visit provider * Read review
AvaTrade
IG

Overview

Editorial rating
3.6 / 5 · SATISFACTORY
4.3 / 5 · GOOD
Costs
3.0 / 5
4.0 / 5
Products
3.5 / 5
4.5 / 5
Platform
4.0 / 5
5.0 / 5
Service
3.5 / 5
3.5 / 5
Safety
4.5 / 5
4.5 / 5
Pros
  • Regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland
  • Copy trading via AvaSocial and DupliTrade
  • MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and proprietary WebTrader
  • Negative balance protection for retail clients
  • Spreads from 1 point on the DAX and 0.6 points on EUR/USD
  • Knock-outs with no commission
  • ProRealTime, MT4, TradingView and L2 Dealer
  • Demo account available for practice
Cons
  • EUR/USD spread from 0.9 pips
  • €50 inactivity fee after 3 months
  • €100 administration fee after 12 months of inactivity
  • Leveraged CFDs: 74% of retail accounts lose money
  • No savings plans
  • Support confirmed only in German and English

Company & account

Broker type
  • Market Maker
  • Market Maker
  • DMA
Founded
–
1974
Headquarters
Dublin, Irland (EU: AVA Trade EU Ltd)
Frankfurt am Main, Deutschland (IG Europe GmbH); Konzern London
Publicly listed
Nein
–
Accepts clients from
EU/EWR über AVA Trade EU Ltd (Irland)
Deutschland über IG Europe GmbH; Angebot nicht für Einwohner der USA und Belgiens
Account types
–
  • IG-Handelskonto
  • IG-Turbo24-Konto
  • IG-Barriers- und Optionenkonto
  • professionelles IG-Konto
  • Firmenkonto
Minimum deposit
€100
–
Corporate account
–
Yes
Demo account
–
Yes

Tradable products

Products
  • CFDs
  • Forex
  • Indizes
  • Rohstoffe
  • Optionen
  • CFDs
  • Forex
  • Indizes
  • Rohstoffe
  • Krypto-CFDs
  • Knock-outs
  • Optionen
Savings plans
No
No

Fees & costs

Order fee
Spreads ab 0,9 Pips (EUR/USD), keine separate Kommission
Spreads ab 1 Punkt DAX, ab 0,6 Punkte EUR/USD; Knock-outs 0 € Kommission
German stock (Xetra)
–
nur Aktien-CFDs: 0,05 %, mind. 5 € je Transaktion (online), 15 € telefonisch
US stock
–
nur Aktien-CFDs: 2 Cent je Aktie, mind. 10 $ (online)
Options per contract
–
0,10 der Handelswährung je Kontrakt bei Eröffnung und Schließung (Knock-outs und Optionen)
EUR/USD spread
ab 0,9 Pips
ab 0,9 Pips (Mindestspread, CFD)
Forex commission
keine separate Kommission (im Spread enthalten)
keine Kommission – Kosten nur im Spread (CFDs außer Aktien-CFDs)
Account fee
–
0 € Kontoeröffnung; ProRealTime 30 € pro Monat (Erstattung ab 4 Trades im Monat)
Inactivity fee
50 € nach 3 Monaten ohne Nutzung; zusätzlich Verwaltungsgebühr 100 € nach 12 Monaten ohne Nutzung (EUR-Konto)
–
Overnight financing
–
Übernachtfinanzierung für Positionen, die nach 23:00 Uhr MEZ offen bleiben; 50 $ Gebühr bei fehlendem W-8/W-9-Formular für US-Aktien

Trading & platforms

Execution model
–
Market Maker (OTC-Hebelprodukte), Absicherung nur bei einseitigem Kundenexposure; DMA für Forex- und Aktien-CFDs über L2 Dealer
Trading platforms
  • WebTrader
  • MetaTrader 4
  • MetaTrader 5
  • AvaSocial
  • DupliTrade
  • eigene Web-Plattform
  • iOS-App
  • Android-App
  • MetaTrader 4
  • ProRealTime
  • TradingView
  • L2 Dealer
Max. leverage (retail)
1:30
1:30 (Hauptwährungspaare), Indizes 1:20
Copy/social trading
Yes
–
API access
–
Yes
Algo trading / EAs
Yes
Yes

Deposits & withdrawals

Deposit methods
  • Kreditkarte
  • Banküberweisung
  • Kreditkarte
  • Debitkarte
  • PayPal
  • Apple Pay
  • Banküberweisung

Safety & regulation

Regulators
  • Central Bank of Ireland
  • CySEC
  • ASIC
  • FSCA
  • FSA Japan
  • FSRA (ADGM)
  • FSC BVI
  • CMA Kenia
  • BaFin
  • Deutsche Bundesbank
Legal entities
  • AVA Trade EU Ltd – Central Bank of Ireland (EU)
  • DT Direct Investment Hub Ltd – CySEC (Zypern)
  • Ava Capital Markets Australia Pty Ltd – ASIC
  • Ava Capital Markets Pty Ltd – FSCA (Südafrika)
  • Ava Trade Japan K.K. – FSA Japan
  • Ava Trade Middle East Ltd – FSRA (ADGM)
  • Ava Trade Markets Ltd – FSC BVI
  • Ava Trade Kenya Limited – CMA Kenia
  • IG Europe GmbH, Frankfurt am Main – BaFin und Deutsche Bundesbank
Licence numbers
  • Central Bank of Ireland C53877
  • CySEC 347/17
  • ASIC 406684
  • FSCA FSP 45984
  • FSA Japan 1662
  • FSRA (ADGM) 190018
  • FSC BVI SIBA/L/13/1049
  • CMA Kenia 262
  • BaFin-Registernummer 148759
Deposit protection
Investor Compensation Scheme (Irland): 90 % der Forderung, max. 20.000 € für Privatkunden
–
Investor compensation
90 % der Forderung, max. 20.000 € (Investor Compensation Scheme, Irland)
90 % der Forderung, max. 20.000 € (EdW)
Negative balance protection
Yes
Yes
Segregated client funds
–
Yes
CFD loss rate
–
74 %

Service & support

Support channels
–
  • Live-Chat
  • WhatsApp
Support hours
–
24/7 über digitale Kanäle
Support languages
  • de
  • en
  • Deutsch
Education
–
IG Academy, Trading-Webinare und Seminare, Demokonto
Straight to the provider

Disclosure: some links to providers are affiliate links. We may earn a commission – the price for you stays the same and our ratings remain independent.

More comparisons