On brokercheck24.com we compare online brokers, neobrokers and crypto platforms using a fixed scheme that anyone can look up. So that you can trace every score, this page explains which criteria we assess, how they are weighted and where our data comes from.
Five sub-scores, one overall score
Every provider receives a sub-score between 0 and 5 in five categories. From these sub-scores we calculate the overall score as a weighted average, rounded to one decimal place.
| Category | Weighting | What we assess |
|---|---|---|
| Costs | 30% | Order fees, custody fees, savings plan costs, spreads |
| Offering | 25% | Tradable assets, savings plans, trading venues |
| Safety | 20% | Supervision, deposit protection and investor compensation, track record and sanctions |
| Platform | 15% | Web, app, desktop, demo account, features |
| Service | 10% | Languages, support channels |
Costs carry the greatest weight because fees eat directly into your returns, year after year. Safety follows close behind: a cheap broker is of little use to you if supervision and protection schemes are not up to scratch.
Worked example
A fictitious broker achieves the following sub-scores: costs 4.5, offering 4.0, platform 4.0, service 3.5 and safety 5.0. The calculation is:
4.5 Γ 0.30 + 4.0 Γ 0.25 + 4.0 Γ 0.15 + 3.5 Γ 0.10 + 5.0 Γ 0.20 = 4.30
The overall score is therefore 4.3 out of 5.
The criteria in detail
Costs (30%)
We look at what an order actually costs, whether custody fees apply, what it costs to run a savings plan and how wide the spreads are. Costs that are hard to find count towards the score just as much as clearly published fees.
Offering (25%)
What matters here is which assets you can trade β for example shares, ETFs, funds, bonds, derivatives or crypto-assets β, how wide the choice of savings plans is and on which trading venues your orders can be executed.
Platform (15%)
We assess whether the broker offers a web interface, an app and desktop software, whether there is a demo account to try things out and which features are available, such as order types, charts or watchlists.
Service (10%)
The key questions are which languages you can get help in and through which channels you can reach customer support, for instance by phone, email or chat.
Safety (20%)
We check who supervises the provider: Germany's BaFin, another EU supervisory authority with an EU passport or β for crypto-assets β an authorisation under the European MiCA Regulation. We also look at deposit protection and investor compensation, as well as the provider's track record, including any known sanctions imposed by supervisory authorities.
Where our data comes from
Every rating is based on the providers' official price lists and websites. For every piece of information we state the source and the date on which we checked it, so you can see at a glance how up to date it is. Providers change their terms regularly β the current information published by the provider itself is always what counts.
Independence and partner commissions
We fund brokercheck24.com through partner commissions: if you open an account via one of our links, the provider may pay us a fee. These commissions have no influence on scores or rankings. The order in our comparisons is determined solely by the rating. Featured placements are clearly labelled as advertisements.
Limits of our ratings
A score condenses a great deal of detail into a single number. Which broker suits you depends on your own goals: someone paying into an ETF savings plan every month needs something different from someone who trades individual shares frequently. Use the sub-scores to compare precisely the areas that matter to you. Our ratings are not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any particular financial product.
Spotted a mistake?
If you notice outdated or incorrect information, please let us know via our contact page. We review every report and update the rating where necessary.